The American Film Institute has spoken once again, choosing the 100 most romantic films of all time in their 100 Years... 100 Passions TV show, broadcast on Tuesday, June 11. After publishing a list of 400 romantic films, they asked a panel of 1,800 experts to vote on them and choose the 100 best. Here were their criteria:
FEATURE-LENGTH FICTION FILM - Narrative format, typically over 60 minutes in length.
AMERICAN FILM - English language film with significant creative and/or production elements from the United States.
LOVE STORY - Regardless of genre, a romantic bond between two or more characters, whose actions and/or intentions provide the heart of the film�s narrative.
LEGACY - Films whose "passions" have enriched America�s film and cultural heritage while continuing to inspire contemporary artists and audiences.
Here's the complete list of the nominees. There's also a printable version if you'd like to have that for reference. It's very long, as you can imagine, so be sure you have lots of paper in your printer.
Some of the films that were missing included:
The Adventures Of Robin Hood
Arizona Dream
The Band Wagon
Dodsworth
Flying Down To Rio
Follow The Fleet
Here Comes Mr. Jordan
High Sierra
His Kind Of Woman
Holiday Affair
The Horse Whisperer
How To Steal A Million
In A Lonely Place
Keeper Of The Flame
The Mortal Storm
Penny Serenade
Rachel and the Stranger
River Of No Return
Robin Hood, Prince Of Thieves
Shall We Dance
They Drive By Night
To Each His Own
Without Love
Many of these films were suggested by members of the Classic Movies Forum.
Instead of a poll to determine what your 100 favorites are, this year I chose what I thought were ten pre-60s films that were likely to show up on the final list and asked you to vote for the one you think most deserves to be Number One -- not which one you think will win, mind you (or which is your personal favorite, which is something else entirely), but which one you think is most deserving of the honor.
How'd We Do?
Well, the results are mixed. Aside from The Quiet Man, which I suspect was a case of ballot-box stuffing that unfortunately can't be prevented with the poll format we use, we did pretty well with the #1 and #2 choices, Casablanca and Gone With the Wind. Our 5th choice, Roman Holiday, came in 4th. I left the #3 choice, West Side Story, and #5, An Affair to Remember, off my list of poll choices completely (mea culpa). Our 4th, 6th, and 7th choices were not in the top 10, and the rest got only a smattering of votes. It was a pleasant surprise to see City Lights finish 10th. But classic film fans hated to see Moonstruck, Love Story, and Ghost finishing higher than Now, Voyager, The Lady Eve, and The Philadelphia Story! Okay, here's the final list:
100. Jerry MacGuire
99. Pillow Talk
98. The Hunchback of Notre Dame
97. Grease
96. Barefoot in the Park
95. Lady & The Tramp
94. Body Heat
93. Dirty Dancing
92. Porgy and Bess
91. Working Girl
90. The Bridges of Madison County
89. Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolfe?
88. The Princess Bride
87. The Unbearable Lightness of Being
86. Notorious
85. Love Is A Many Splendored Thing
84. Double Indemnity
83. Morocco
82. Witness
81. The Goodbye Girl
80. The Shiek
79. Jezebel
78. Coming Home
77. The Awful Truth
76. The Quiet Man
75. The American President
74. Woman Of The Year
73. The Ghost and Mrs Muir
72. Roxanne
71. Way Down East
70. Sense & Sensibility
69. Harold and Maude
68. What's Up Doc?
67. A Streetcar Named Desire
66. Manhattan
65. Bonnie & Clyde
64. Marty
63. Sunrise
62. The Apartment
61. Breakfast at Tiffany's
60. To Have and Have Not
59. Picnic
58. Guess Who's Coming to Dinner?
57. Two For The Road
56. The English Patient
55. Reds
54. Sabrina
53. A Place in The Sun
52. The Graduate
51. Bringing Up Baby
50. Shakespeare In Love
49. The Postman Always Rings Twice
48. Last Tango In Paris
47. Splendor In The Grass
46. To Catch a Thief
45. Sleepless In Seattle
44. The Philadelphia Story
43. A Star Is Born (1954)
42. Anna Karenina (1935)
41. Funny Girl
40. Ninotchka
39. An American In Paris
38. It Happened One Night
37. Titanic (1996)
36. Random Harvest
35. Gigi
34. Beauty & The Beast
33. Camille
32. Dark Victory
31. The King & I
30. Swing Time
29. An Officer & A Gentleman
28. The Shop Around the Corner
27. The Sound of Music
26. The Lady Eve
25. When Harry Met Sally
24. King Kong
23. Now, Voyager
22. On Golden Pond
21. Pretty Woman
20. From Here to Eternity
19. Ghost
18. Vertigo
17. Moonstruck
16. Singin' in The Rain
15. Wuthering Heights
14. The African Queen
13. Out Of Africa
12. My Fair Lady
11. Annie Hall
10. City Lights
9. Love Story
8. It's a Wonderful Life
7. Dr. Zhivago
6. The Way We Were
5. An Affair to Remember
4. Roman Holiday
3. West Side Story
2. Gone With The Wind
1. Casablanca